ulysses and the mast
The goddess Circe warned Ulysses (or Odysseus) of the sirens and their bewitching song. While his men plugged their ears with wax, Ulysses, consumed with curiosity, wished to listen. Per Circe’s command, his crew tied him to the mast with knotted rope, so he would not join the “great heaps of men, flesh rotting from their bones, their skin all shriveled up” (Wilson, 12.46-7). To maximize his own autonomy—to listen to the Sirens when no one else could—he had to restrict himself.
Jon Elster’s Ulysses and the Sirens argues that the deepest expression of autonomy is precommitment. To stay true to his overarching goals and values, Ulysses chose to bind his future self and avoid temptation and impulse. We confuse autonomy with the lack of constraints, but the free individual is the very author of her own constraints. Delete that app, keep the sabbath, submit to an editor, honor that debt! Consider and formulate your own bindings.
As we will see in the two Shadow meditations below, the ideal of precommitment is an easy discriminator between true and false autonomies. The Free-Thinker refuses all restrictions and is thus governed by impulse. The Contrarian accepts constraints she never examined. The Erudite is lashed to the mast on her own orders.