the sultan

and now, war with persia!

Americans are overwhelmingly united in their recognition and hatred of political corruption. Over the last many decades, the ruling and moneyed class has systematically dismantled even the meager safeguards present against the total unity of wealth and power, wealth and legal impunity, wealth and moral hazard. Everywhere there is talk of “oligarchy,” a vague taxonomy of species: industrial tycoons, dynastic heirs, reptilian tech billionaires, the “globalist class,” and mega-donors spinning dark-money webs. Let’s examine the word “oligarch,” particularly one of its subvarieties—the “sultanistic oligarchy”—that increasingly defines the patronage landscape of the United States under Donald Trump.

Plato’s Republic defines an oligarchy as a political system “resting on a valuation of property, in which the rich have power, and the poor man is deprived of it.” It is contrasted with the rule of those with wisdom, virtue, or military honor, and constitutes an elite, insatiably addicted to wealth. Because of severe wealth gaps, vagrancy, crime, and beggary are pervasive. Plato’s disciple Aristotle further contrasted oligarchy against aristocracy, both manifestations of “rule by the few,” though the former possesses a self-interested elite, the latter an elite concerned with the commonweal. To Chris Buskirk, the conservative media figure who co-founded the 1789 Capital venture firm close to the Trump family, the distinction, ironically, is between an extractive and a productive upper class.

Oligarchy, by Jeffrey A. Winters, is considered a seminal text in the field and offers the most precise definition. An oligarch is a person whose political power comes from their massive material wealth. In turn, an oligarchy is a political system in which oligarchs defend and amass wealth.

If the political power of the oligarchic class is derived solely from their wealth, then the oligarch’s top priority is NOT to amass more wealth, but to DEFEND their wealth. In other words, the greedy are more obsessed with loss than gain. Wealth accumulation can indeed be a primary strategy to hedge against loss, but it is ultimately the loss of wealth that consumes the oligarch’s mind and spirit. Obsession with loss renders a person existentially revolted by charity, taxation, donation, and costly activities that do not immediately and tangibly refund profit.

Winters puts forth four subvarieties of oligarchy—warring, ruling, civil, and sultanistic. The primary distinctions are along two axes: 1) whether the oligarchs are collectivized/disbanded, and 2) whether they are militarized or demilitarized. Of further importance is whether the threats to their wealth are from “the have-nots ‘below,’ laterally [from the ‘side’] from other oligarchs, from a sultanistic ruler or state from ‘above,’ or from some combination of these.”

Warring oligarchies (disbanded and militarized) are common in the detritus of fallen empires. They are the opportunistic creatures of interregnum. Their eventual endpoint is the formation of ruling oligarchies (collectivized and militarized), which allow the elites to ignore the once-deadly, omnipresent threat: attacks from “individual predatory oligarchs locally or collectivities of oligarchs attacking from abroad.”

The United States has long been a classic example of civil oligarchy, in which all the oligarchs get together and agree that the most stable and predictable way to defend their wealth is through legal, bureaucratic, and judicial institutions, rather than maintaining their own standing armies. In this case, democracy or a flawed democracy coexists with oligarchy; all that is required are legal tools like lobbying, campaign finance, and tax policy.

Winters considered Putin’s Russia as the ideal model of the fourth, the sultanistic oligarchy, though he is now “seeing those tendencies closer to home.” The sultanistic system is a form under a single, dominant, and supreme oligarch at the top of the patronage pyramid. This sultan rules directly and personally. All other oligarchs can get extraordinarily wealthy in proximity to the sultan or through the sultan’s protection, yet they can just as easily have everything stripped away by his vicissitudes. The sultan can make or break you. There are no property rights, merely claims.

The system is paternalistic, in which the sultan acts like a domineering father over the household, dispensing favors and punishments at will. His sons, the princelings, run around with unmatched access and near-total impunity, treated like royalty, for they are the blood and bone of the sultan.

Distinction between private and public governance is murkier and murkier. Conflict of interest is definitionally impossible when both spheres are one and the same. Plato describes the formation of an oligarchy as the purchase of political power by a wealthy class. It is a platitude to say that money buys political power. Yet in the current administration, the process is reversing: political power is the engine driving unfathomable wealth extraction. We are witnessing the consolidation of one oligarchic family over its genuflecting rivals. Trump and his underlings no longer desire a system where wealth alone is the precondition for power, but one in which power is the precondition for wealth. Perhaps the sultanistic typology is not oligarchy at all, but a hybrid kleptocratic or patrimonial regime which employs oligarchs as courtiers. Then is the sultan defending the collective’s wealth, ruthlessly extracting from it, or both?

As Noah Shachtman reports in the Times, in the golden and mirrored halls of Mar-a-Lago, World Liberty Financial (an extraordinarily corrupt entity that has made billions for the Trump family in crypto) held a conference in February with scores of CEOs, investment bankers, stock exchange presidents, tycoons, and titans of industry in attendance (as well as Nicki Minaj!). All there purportedly to discuss “the future of finance and technology.” Behind the speaker podium on the stage was a vast, golden eagle. Shachtman perfectly captures: “It didn’t look exactly like the [eagle] on the presidential seal, but it didn’t look all that different, either.”

lmk!