the contrarian

The Contrarian is governed entirely by what she opposes. Her positions are computable from her enemies’. We associate intellectual and cultural superiority with dissidence and nonconformity, and often rightly so! Yet when you simply manufacture dissent for the sake of dissenting (or worse, for provocation), you are naïve. The conformist does not examine their opinions but moves with the ebbs and flows of the mainstream. The non-conformist, without critical thinking, merely reacts, parasitic on whatever the mainstream happens to be. She is pure negation.

And so the thoughtless contrarian is equivalent in method to the thoughtless conformist. Evil doesn’t have to arise from malice or conviction, but by the lack of what Hannah Arendt calls the “two-in-one.” That conversation between me and myself, the act of thinking as a perpetual self-interrogation. Because even solitary thinking is structured as a relationship, the Self can be divided into speaker and auditor and audience. To be truly present in your own thoughts is to confront and question your convictions. If you neglect to self-legislate and introspect, if you outsource judgment, that vacancy will blind you to what is good or bad. Arendt calls this process the “banality of evil,” which is thoughtlessness and reflexive obedience that lead ordinary people to commit horrific acts. Autonomy cannot be downstream from blind opposition.

lmk!