greed for the new
Curiosity has been on trial since humanity acquired it. It is the quality of Eve and Adam, of Hamlet and Einstein, of Sherlock Holmes and Scheherazade, of Sun Wukong and Sartre, of Cicero and cats and Black Mirror. German philosopher Hans Blumenberg traces the word’s long history and its conversion from sin to virtue in “The Trial of Theoretical Curiosity.”
The greats of Classical Antiquity acknowledged the importance of knowing (both the world and thyself). But the pursuit of abstract knowledge was savagely attacked. St. Augustine saw curiosity as a vice because it overturns the established order of things. Curiosity, to Augustine, seeks to make God ‘useful’ for our ‘enjoyment.’ Instead of focusing on salvation, we waste time engaging with our fallen world. Curiosity, in the medieval realm, was a flaw. Some knowledge is reserved for God (secreta naturae) and that’s too bad for you.
Yet scholasticism eventually collapsed. Nominalism, arguing that universal concepts are mere names rather than objective realities, undermined the medieval synthesis of faith and reason. Everything could now be subjective, determined by individual impression or linguistic convention. This gave us humans a license to investigate the world.
Francis Bacon was instrumental in reversing curiosity from a transgression to an obligation. He illustrated it as the restoration of dominion lost at the Fall. This began the SLOW process of untangling guilt from curiosity, turning the urge to uncover secrets into the foundation of modern science. Blumenberg argues that modernity is exactly the self-assertion of curiosity against imposed limits. Yet just as it has been forever, there are forces that want the boundaries narrowed, the thresholds barred.
I will give the final word to Eça de Queiroz:
“Curiosity, an instinct of infinite complexity, may lead one to listen at doors or to discover America – yet both these impulses, so different in terms of dignity and results, spring from an intrinsically precious source, the activity of the mind.”